New space, new person: Agnès Riva
What tension arises between visionary designs and the complex urban reality? Agnès Riva's latest book, "Un autre ailleurs" (2025), explores the genesis of New Créteil in 1973, focusing on the perspective of 23-year-old "animator" Gilles. Initially, he is deeply fascinated by the modernity and revolutionary potential of Créteil, which, for him, "is springing from the ground" and is a "brand-new landscape, an incarnation of the future" where "everything seemed possible, including a new life." Agnès Riva understands the city of Créteil as a "space of memory and imagination" as well as a "romantic laboratory" for illuminating the history of the "new city." The study begins by presenting the initial modernist-utopian visions for such planned cities, which were heavily influenced by Le Corbusier's ideas of radical redesign and functionality. This initial enthusiasm is illustrated by the novel's protagonist, Gilles, who sees Créteil as a "brand-new landscape, the incarnation of the future" and underscores the idea of a new beginning with the slogan "New space, new man!" The core of the argument then lies in the gradual disillusionment: The article shows how the lofty utopian promises begin to crack in the inhabitants' real experience, characterized by "generic and interchangeable architecture," feelings of "being trapped," and social problems. This disillusionment is deepened by Henri Lefebvre's well-founded theoretical critique of modern urbanism, particularly through his concepts of the "right to the city" and the distinction between the lived "habiter" and the planned "habitat," as well as the loss of the "work" in favor of the "product." In conclusion, the article argues that despite these dominant tendencies of planned urbanism, elements of resistance and appropriation exist that embrace an “urban revolution” as a “real development” and thus suggest a redefinition of utopian hopes, rather than simply stating a failure of utopia.
➙ To the article